Delaware Bankruptcy Insider:
Be In The Know
About This Blog
The Delaware Bankruptcy Insider is a premier blog designed to bring its readers a comprehensive analysis of the latest Delaware corporate bankruptcy news and rulings. Brought to you by Ashby & Geddes, P.A.
Judges and Courts
- Delaware Court of Chancery
- Delaware District Court
- Delaware Supreme Court
- Judge Brendan L. Shannon
- Judge Christopher S. Sontchi
- Judge Kevin Gross
- Judge Kevin J. Carey
- Judge Laurie Selber Silverstein
- Judge Mary F. Walrath
- Judge Peter J. Walsh
- Third Circuit Court of Appeals
- United States Supreme Court
- Getting Noticed in the Digital Age: Delaware Bankruptcy Court Finds Email Notice Satisfies Due Process but Not Rule 2002
- Third Circuit Reversal Paves the Way For NextEra to Potentially Recover Administrative Expenses Incurred in Connection With Failed Merger
- Delaware District Court Disagrees with Bankruptcy Court’s Ruling and Holds That Committee’s Challenge Rights Survived Entry of the Sale Order and Consummation of Sale
For more information
Ricardo Palacio, Esq.
Gregory A. Taylor, Esq.
Ashby & Geddes, P.A.
500 Delaware Avenue
P.O. Box 1150
Wilmington, Delaware 19899-1150
Subsidiary Can Exercise Actual Control Over Parent Sufficient to Create a Fiduciary Relationship Says Bankruptcy Court
Burtch v. Owlstone, Inc. (In re Advance Nanotech, Inc.), Adv. No. 13-51215 (MFW), 2014 WL 1320145 (Bankr. D. Del. Apr. 2, 2014)
On April 2, 2014, the Honorable Mary F. Walrath issued a Memorandum Opinion denying a motion to dismiss brought by a non-debtor subsidiary challenging breach of fiduciary duty claims asserted by a chapter 7 trustee on behalf of a bankrupt-parent. In doing so, the Court made an interesting (and perhaps controversial) conclusion – it is possible for a subsidiary to exercise actual control over its parent sufficient to create a fiduciary obligation.
In 2004, Advance Nanotech, Inc. (“AVNA”) acquired a 60% ownership interest in Owlstone, Inc. (“Owlstone”) and became its principal funding source. In 2007 and 2008, AVNA generated $7.42 million for Owlstone’s operations by issuing notes (“Senior Secured Notes”) secured by its equity in Owlstone. In return for its investment, AVNA’s equity interest in Owlstone increased to 83.1%. It also became the holder of $2.64 million of Owlstone’s debt. Critically, following the transaction, AVNA fired its CEO and CFO, and hired Owlstone’s CEO and CFO (Bader and Finn, respectively). Bader and Finn continued to serve as Owlstone’s CEO and CFO.
Shortly thereafter, both AVNA and Owlstone faced a liquidity crisis. Bader and Finn, tasked with fundraising for AVNA, negotiated a $1.7 million bridge loan with Ingalls & Snyder, LLC (“I & S”), a holder of AVNA’s Senior Secured Notes. Attempts at further fundraising through a sale of AVNA stock failed when AVNA could not obtain unanimous consent of the holders of the Senior Secured Notes, which was a prerequisite to any dilution of AVNA stock. Failing to raise funds through a sale of AVNA stock, it is alleged that Bader, with the advice of an I & S principal, had Owlstone offer its own stock for sale, which did not necessitate noteholder consent. While the sale raised funds for Owlstone, it severely diluted AVNA’s ownership interest in Owlstone. Thereafter, Bader and Finn resigned from their CEO and CFO positions at AVNA, but remained on with Owlstone. With no cash and diluted assets, AVNA defaulted on its Senior Secured Notes and, on March 15, 2011, was forced into an involuntary chapter 7 proceeding. The instant complaint was commenced by the chapter 7 trustee (the “Trustee”) against Owlstone for, among other things, breach of fiduciary duties created by actual control.* Owlstone moved to dismiss, arguing that the notion that a subsidiary can control its parent is contrary to settled law and common sense.
The Bankruptcy Court began its analysis by noting that, in Delaware, a fiduciary relationship does not exist between a debtor and a creditor unless control “is established by facts demonstrating that ‘through personal or other relationships the [individuals] are beholden to the controlling person.’” Edgewater Growth Capital Partners LP v. H.I.G. Capital Inc., 68 A.3d 197, 229-30 (Del. Ch. 2013) (internal citation omitted). Contrary to Owlstone’s argument that settled law dictates that a subsidiary cannot control its parent, the Court found that the cases cited by Owlstone in support “merely assumed that, as a general rule, subsidiaries are subject to the direction and control of their parent entities.” Notably, the Court concluded that “[t]here is no legal principle that states a subsidiary can never exercise actual control over its parent.” The Court further noted that if, during AVNA’s fundraising process, the CEO and CFO of AVNA (who also served in those roles for Owlstone) “switched sides” to act for Owlstone’s benefit, Owlstone may have acted to control AVNA’s fundraising process and by extension AVNA itself, thereby creating fiduciary obligations owed by Owlstone to AVNA. Applying the facts to these legal conclusions, the Court ultimately permitted the Trustee’s claim for breach of fiduciary duty to survive because, drawing all inferences in favor of the Trustee, the complaint alleged sufficient facts to make the aforementioned scenario “plausible”.
This novel concept, that a subsidiary can exert actual control over its parent notwithstanding the parent’s super-majority ownership of the subsidiary’s outstanding stock, will likely be the focus of future litigation in the Delaware Bankruptcy Court and elsewhere, especially if chapter 7 trustees pursue this avenue of recovery against profitable non-debtor subsidiaries. However, parties should be mindful of the procedural posture of the case, which on a motion to dismiss forced the Court to draw all reasonable inferences in favor of the non-moving party, as well as the unique circumstances under which the ruling was made. We will continue to monitor the proceedings as they develop and look forward to the inevitable commentary to come regarding the Court’s conclusions.
*The Trustee also brought claims against Owlstone for aiding and abetting breaches of fiduciary duty and equitable subordination. In addition, I & S as well as one of its principals faced claims for breaches of fiduciary duty and aiding and abetting breaches of fiduciary duty. Ultimately, the Court refused to dismiss the claims against Owlstone, I & S, and the principal for aiding and abetting breaches of fiduciary duty. Similarly, the Court denied dismissal of the equitable subordination claim asserted against Owlstone. Despite the foregoing, the Court granted partial dismissal of the breach of fiduciary duty claims against I & S and the principal, holding that the Trustee’s allegations were insufficient to infer actual control over AVNA by these defendants and thus the creation of fiduciary duties. Leave to amend the complaint, however, was granted.
38 thoughts on “Subsidiary Can Exercise Actual Control Over Parent Sufficient to Create a Fiduciary Relationship Says Bankruptcy Court”
Discovering adore in Florida can be a toough practical experience, but itt
doesn’t need to be. There are plenty of approaches to fulfill men and women from thee Sun State, regardless of whether you’re seeking somebody special within your group or farther afield.
California is definitely a spot of wonderful organic beauty.
In the seashores within the sough to the mountain rangees within the too the north, there is anything for everykne to enjoy.
One oof thhe most well-known attractions within the condition is Yosemite Countrywide Playground.
The recreation area houses among the most stunning countryside iin North America, such as Fifvty percent
Domme annd El Capitan.
There are lots of online dating sites that serve distinct
people, so it’s vital that you select one that suits you.
on the internet datin in chi town might be a great way
to get in touch with somebody that gives your pursuits and principles.
Because of so many men and woken on-line, there will certainly be
a person on the markett who iis great for you.
Consider joinming video games conventions or meetups.
Thee can bee great locations to meet like-minded men and
women and poteentially find a date. After some work, courtinng for gamers can be
a entertaining and gratifying encounter.
Try attending game playing events orr meetups.
These can be wonderful areas to satisfy like-minded individuals and potentially locate a particular
date. With a little effort, dating for gamers can be quite a exciting aand fulfilling encounter.
Based on research, yoou can find over 6.4 million single men and women inn Texas.
That’s lots of people who are on the market searching for love!
Attempt joining game playing events or meetups. These can be great areqs in order to meet like-minded
individuals and potentially get a time. With a bit of energy,
internet dating for gamers can be a fun and safisfying practical experience.
Consider participating in video gaming events or meetups.
This can bee fantastic spots to meet like-minded individuals and potentially find a date.
With a bit of hard work, online dating for gamers could be a enjoyable aand rewarding practical experience.
As outlined by reesearch conducted recently, there are actually
over 6.4 million singles in Tx. That’s many people who
definitely are ouut there searching forr adore!
Preferred dating sites and apps can sometimes be overwhelming and full of phoony profiles.
It is essential to do your homework and select an established
site orr app before building a user profile.
Texas is a good place for men annd women tto have,
operate and engage in. Their state has a lot of stuff selecting it:
the Alamo, Tex-Mex cuisine, the Dalloas Cowboys plus more.
California has long ben an area of fantastic natural charm.
In the beach locations inside the south for the hills from the northern, there exists something for everybody to experience.
Just about the most popular aattractions inside the condition is Yosemite Federal Recreation area.
The recreation area is home to many of thhe most beasutiful landscapes in North America, which includ Half Dome and El Capitan.
The dating scenario in Chi town is ass different as the city on its own. There are
nunerous different kinds of people dwelling
here that it’s impossible not to find someone you’re interested
iin or discuss interests with. You just need to know thee best places to look!
Whoever has been within a romantic relationship is aware they can be both exhilarating and stressful.
In the very first butterflies of a neew romantic endeavors on the comfort of an extensive-phrase partnership, relationships come in all styles and sizes.
Well-known dating sites and apps caan occasionally be
mind-boggling and full of bogus user profiles. You should ddo your homework and
select a reputable web site orr app before making a information.
Dating iin Florida can be a tad tough, particularly if you’re not
used to the temperature and humidity. But there are
several online dating possibilities once you learn where you should seem.
The right spot to get started on is on the web,
to find a Flolrida courting website tgat fits your requirements.
As soon as you’ve identified an effective internet site, join aand make up a account.
Be suree you include a number of pictures and some specifics off oneself.
Then lolk around to see who grazbs your eyes. If you’re feeling daring, you may
even try dating in other areas of your express.
Just be sure you continue to be safe and have fun!
Getting love in Florida might be a demanding expertise, nevertheless iit
doesn’t really need to be. There are many strategies to meet singles
within the Sunlight Status, reardless of whether you’re seeking somebody special within your group or farthe afield.
Try attending gaming events or meetups. This can be fantastic spots in order to meet like-minded men and women aand potentially find a particular
date. After some energy, onlinee dating for gamers can bbe quite
a fun and fulfilling encounter.
Anyone who has ever ever been in a relationship is aware that they
could be bith thrilling and stressful. From the initial
butterflies of the new romancee on the comfort of an extended-term
collaboration, relationships are availabpe in all shapes and sizes.
Anyone who has evcer been inside a relationship is aware they can be both
thrilling and tiring. From your very first butterflies of your nnew romantic endeavors for the convenience of an extended-word collaboration, connections are available in all sixes and shapes.
Online dating can be a exciting and fuun approach to make new friends and begin a
fresh connection. Even so, it could also be a ttle bit overpowering,
particulardly if you’re unclear how to begin.
Texas is a great locdation for men and women to live, job and enjoy.
The statee has a lot of stuff opting for it: the Alamo, Tex-Mex dishes, the Dallas Cowboys and more.
Texas is a good area for men and women to reside, function and perform.
Their state has many points opting for it: the Alamo, Tex-Mex meals, the Dallas Cowboyss ppus more.
Internet dating could be a fun aand excitimg approach to meet new people and
begin a brand new relationship. Nevertheless,
it is also a bit overwhelming, especially if you’re unsure
how to begin.
Dating can be a exciting and fun strategy to meet new people and begin a
new connection. However, it coulld also be somewhat frustrating,
especially if you’re unsure where to begin.
Popular dating sites and apps is often mind-boggling and packed with phony
user profiles. You should do your research and judge a professional site
or app beforee creating a account.
Courting cann be a exciting and fun approach to meet new peopl and commence a whole nnew
romantic relationship. Nevertheless,it can also be a little mind-boggling,
particularly when you’re unsue how to start.
I was more than happy to search out this web-site.
바카라사이트 , 얀카지노 , 바카라사이트 , 바카라사이트 , 먹튀검증토토 , 바카라사이트 , 바카라사이트 , 스포츠토토 , 카지노드라마 , 안전놀이터 , 온카모아
Dear ashbygeddes.com administrator, Your posts are always well-supported and evidence-based.
To the ashbygeddes.com admin, Your posts are always informative and well-explained.
Hello ashbygeddes.com owner, Thanks for the great post!
Hi ashbygeddes.com administrator, You always provide useful information.
Hi ashbygeddes.com webmaster, Your posts are always well-formatted and easy to read.
Hi ashbygeddes.com owner, Your posts are always well-balanced and objective.
Hello ashbygeddes.com owner, Thanks for the well written post!
Dear ashbygeddes.com administrator, Your posts are always insightful and valuable.
Hello ashbygeddes.com webmaster, You always provide valuable information.
To the ashbygeddes.com admin, Thanks for the well-researched and well-written post!